Today’s Strategic Alignment Journal Post in two sentences:

A request for customer service training became a six-country customer journey mapping engagement because one question revealed that the problem had been misdiagnosed. Return on Decision begins before execution: it is determined by whether we solve the visible problem we were given or take the time to find the real one.

---

A client came to me certain of two things: what the problem was, and how to fix it.

The problem, they said, was customer service. The fix was training. Their frontline people needed to be better with customers, so the plan was to put them through a customer service programme. Clear problem. Clear solution. All that remained was to book it.

Instead I asked why.

I wasn’t being difficult. Something just didn’t sit right. “Customer service” was being treated as a thing that lived at the front desk, separate from everything else. But service isn’t a department. It’s what a customer experiences at every point along the way – before they reach a frontline person, and after. So instead of accepting the problem as presented, I started asking about the whole customer journey. Where do people first encounter you? What happens at each stage? Where does it break down? What do they need, and when?

The executive director got curious. And as we followed the journey, the real picture came into focus — one that a training programme would never have touched.

What began as a request for customer service training became a customer journey mapping engagement across six countries — Trinidad, Grenada, Antigua, Jamaica, Barbados, and Saint Lucia — a shared undertaking with the International Planned Parenthood Federation, its member associations and collaborative partners. Together we mapped the journey stage by stage, identified what each stage actually required, and built the marketing assets and touchpoints needed along the way. The organizations began to see that “customer service” was never a frontline effort at all. It ran through everything.

Here’s what I want you to notice.

If we had done the training — the visible problem, the one they walked in with — the return would have been close to zero. The training itself would not have been bad, but it would have solved the wrong thing beautifully. The people would have been trained, the box would have been ticked, and the real issue — an unmapped, invisible journey — would have sat there untouched, still costing them in the long run.

Every decision carries a return. And the return is largely set before the decision is ever made. In every moment you either accept the problem as presented, or question what’s behind it and whether you’re in the right place.

I call this the Return on Decision.

Most attention goes to how well a decision is executed. But execution can only compound what the diagnosis started. Get the problem right, and everything downstream works in your favour. Get it wrong, and every dollar, every hour, every ounce of effort that follows compounds the error in judgment. The single highest-leverage moment in the entire chain isn’t the solution. It’s the questions that comes before it.

Most advisors accept the problem as presented and start solving. I question what’s behind it first, because if the problem identification itself is off, every solution built on it will be off too.

That’s the whole of it. One question, asked before the money moved, changed what got solved — and changed the return entirely.

Strategic Reflection Prompt

What is one thing in your business you’re currently working to solve — that you accepted as the problem without ever questioning whether it’s the real one?

Before you spend more time, money, or energy on it: are you sure you’re looking in the right place?

About Giselle

Most costly decisions begin with an inaccurate understanding of the situation.

I’m Giselle Hudson – writer and Pre-Decision Diagnostic Advisor. Most advisors offer solutions before carefully diagnosing the situation. I diagnose first — looking for what isn’t completely visible yet. Once we identify that, everything else becomes clearer, and confident, right action can follow.

Through my daily Strategic Alignment Journal, I explore leadership, decision-making, and the patterns that shape organizations, helping leaders make sense of complexity before committing significant time, money, or resources.

What’s the one thing about your business that frustrates you most — the thing that, despite your best efforts, you can’t seem to resolve?