What We Fail to See When We Label

Today’s Strategic Alignment Journal post in two sentences:

When listeners first heard Teena Marie’s voice without seeing her photograph, many assumed she was Black, and discovering otherwise revealed the expectations they had brought to the music. Her story invites us to examine what our own moments of surprise reveal about the labels we apply and the possibilities we may overlook.


When Teena Marie’s first album, Wild and Peaceful, appeared in 1979, her photograph was nowhere to be found. The cover featured a seascape. Listeners heard her powerful R&B voice, and many assumed that the singer was Black.

Then came the surprise. Teena Marie was white.

Nothing about the music had changed. The voice people had embraced was the same one they heard before they knew what she looked like. What changed was the information they had about the person behind it.

The story raises a question that extends well beyond music: What do our reactions reveal about the expectations we carry into an experience?

Hearing Before Seeing

Teena Marie later explained that Motown founder Berry Gordy had chosen not to include her photograph because he wanted the music to be heard on its own merits. He was concerned about how audiences might respond to a white singer performing music rooted in Black musical traditions.

The decision changed the sequence in which listeners encountered her. First came the sound. Only later, for many, came the image.

Her second album, Lady T, released in 1980, displayed her portrait. By then, she had already established a following.

There’s something worth examining in that order. Had people seen her photograph first, would they have listened with the same openness? We cannot know. We do know that many had formed an expectation about her identity, and that learning the truth surprised them.

Surprise is informative. It shows us where reality has departed from the picture we constructed.

What the Surprise Reveals

An assumption isn’t necessarily unreasonable. We draw conclusions from context, experience and familiar patterns every day. A singer’s style may suggest musical influences, and a particular record label may lead listeners to expect certain artists.

The problem arises when we begin treating such expectations as facts, or when they determine what we are willing to recognize.

Teena Marie’s voice didn’t become more or less soulful when people discovered she was white. Her racial identity was relevant to the cultural and commercial circumstances of her career, but it did not retroactively change what listeners had heard.

The surprise wasn’t proof that every listener was prejudiced. It did, however, reveal that people had imagined a person who matched what they expected the music to sound like.

That is the part of the story I find most revealing. Sometimes what surprises us deserves as much examination as what we originally believed.

Surprise can also be uncomfortable, particularly when it reveals that a belief we held with considerable confidence was based on less evidence than we realized.

The Labels We Carry Into Organizations

Organizations rely on categories. We classify roles, customers, capabilities and markets because decisions would be difficult without some way of organizing information.

Yet those categories can begin to function as filters.

A candidate with an unconventional career may be overlooked before anyone examines the capabilities they have developed. An employee may be regarded as unsuitable for leadership because they don’t resemble previous managers. A new service may be dismissed because it doesn’t fit the market segment in which the business has always operated.

In each instance, the category arrives before the evidence has received a fair hearing.

This doesn’t mean every unexpected candidate is suitable, every unfamiliar idea has merit or every classification should be discarded. The issue is whether we know what the category is helping us evaluate, and what it might be preventing us from noticing.

Making Room to Be Surprised

Berry Gordy’s decision did not eliminate the racial boundaries of the music industry. It reflected an awareness that those boundaries could shape an artist’s reception. By allowing listeners to encounter the music first, Motown temporarily withheld information that might have influenced their judgement.

Organizations cannot and should not remove every identifying detail from decisions. They can, however, examine the order in which information is presented and whether their criteria encourage people to look at the actual contribution before making assumptions about its source.

A useful question is not simply, “Does this person or idea fit?” It is, “What are we expecting to see, and why?”

The unexpected does not always reveal something unusual about the person or idea in front of us. Sometimes it reveals how narrowly we had defined what was possible.

Strategic Reflection Prompt

When was the last time someone or something surprised you by challenging an assumption you hadn’t realized you were making?

I’m Giselle Hudson, The Pre-Fixer™.

For nearly three decades, I’ve worked with business owners and leaders across the Caribbean who carry important decisions largely on their own, often when problems keep returning, solutions fall short, or implementation stalls.

When I ask business owners what problem they can’t seem to solve, the answer is usually “people.” So I ask them to tell me more, because people and businesses are rarely as simple as they first appear.

I help them understand what’s really causing the problem before they spend more trying to fix it. And where needed, I help design the solution and guide their teams to put it into practice.

Get Clarity before the Fix.

What are you trying to make sense of right now?