Today’s Strategic Alignment Journal post in two sentences:
Discipline is not always about doing more; sometimes it requires us to recognize when continuing no longer makes sense. The challenge is knowing when the situation calls for greater persistence and when it calls for us to stop, reconsider or change direction.
We tend to recognize discipline when it looks like action.
Getting up earlier. Working harder. Staying the course. Following through. Meeting the deadline. Doing what we said we would do even when we no longer feel like doing it.
There is value in all of that. But I wonder whether our definition of discipline has become too closely associated with more: more effort, more persistence, more activity, more endurance.
Sometimes discipline requires exactly the opposite.
I was reading an interview with Ryan Holiday in which he talked about the Stoic idea of discipline alongside temperance and moderation. He used exercise as an example. For one person, discipline might mean getting off the couch and exercising. For someone who is injured or unwell, discipline might mean resisting the urge to exercise and allowing the body to rest.
Discipline, then, is not about always pushing ourselves to do more. It is about recognizing what the situation requires and responding accordingly.
In our working lives, we often treat persistence as evidence of commitment.
Once we have chosen a direction, launched an initiative or invested significant time and resources into something, continuing can begin to feel like the responsible thing to do. Stopping, slowing down or reconsidering can feel uncomfortably close to giving up.
There are times when discipline means staying with something through the inevitable discomfort that accompanies meaningful work. There are also times when discipline means recognizing that the conditions have changed, the original assumptions no longer apply, the team has reached its capacity, or what we are doing simply is not producing what we expected.
The difficult part is knowing which situation we are in.
A team struggling under the weight of too many priorities may not need another productivity system. A leader facing an important decision may not need to make it faster. An organisation whose latest initiative is failing may not need everyone to work harder at making it succeed.
Sometimes the disciplined response is to slow down long enough to understand what is happening.
That might mean reducing the number of priorities rather than demanding greater productivity. It might mean delaying a decision until there is enough clarity to make it well. It might mean questioning an approach that everyone has become invested in. It might even mean abandoning something that once made perfect sense but no longer does.
None of these choices represents a lack of discipline. Sometimes discipline is knowing when not to push harder. It is recognising what the situation requires and responding accordingly.
So when progress begins to stall, perhaps the question is not, How do we do more? but What does this situation require from us now?
Strategic Reflection Prompt
Think about something you are currently pushing yourself or your team to continue. If you stopped assuming that discipline means pushing harder, what would the situation actually require from you now: more effort, more patience, a different approach, or to stop doing?
About Giselle
Most costly decisions begin with a wrong read of the situation.
I’m Giselle Hudson — The Pre-Fixer. I help leaders see the real problem before they act, in my writing and in my work. I don’t fix; I pre-fix. Most advisers jump to solutions before they’ve found the real problem. I find it first — the part that isn’t fully visible yet. Once we see that clearly, everything else falls into place, and confident, right action can follow.
Through my daily Strategic Alignment Journal, I explore leadership, decision-making, and the patterns that shape organizations — helping leaders make sense of complexity before they commit significant time and money to the wrong thing.
What’s the one thing about your business that frustrates you most — the thing that, despite your best efforts, you can’t seem to resolve?
